I was just reading Pharyngula, and PZ has a post about David Barton which made me smile. Barton loves the naturalistic fallacy, and uses it to “prove” that even without God in the equation, abortion and homosexuality are evil. Naturally, PZ gives him his comeuppance with a quite but effective refutation of his arguments, but I wanted to go into a list of a few things that would also be evil or good in a world where the naturalist fallacy were a basis for human behavior.
1. Infanticide GOOD!
Oh don’t make that face, you knew I’d start here. One behavior that happens fairly regularly in nature is the killing of children. When a new male lion, for example, overthrows the head of a pride of lions, they will often kill the cubs. That way, the mothers aren’t distracted by mommying duties from their baby-making duties with the new alpha, and his genetics get the immediate chance to thrive. And it ain’t just lions, it happens all over the place in the animal kingdom. Obviously, if it happens in nature, it has to be good.








