I got home from band practice last night and the Lovely Lady was about to watch a show called Gates Of Hell on these six locations on earth that were generally considered by those who lived in the area to be gateways to the underworld. We thought it might be fascinating, a look at the archeology of the areas, the myths of the various people who lived in the areas, and maybe even an exploration of some of these places. In some regards that was correct, but for the most part it was yet another shitty program featuring horrible reporting, ridiculous conjecture, and more stupid than one could shake a stick at.
One point in particular gives example of this. They were in Belize with an archeologist walking through this particular set of caves that the Mayans had believed were the houses of various torments in the underworld. Unlike most other cultures, this underworld was one that the Mayans entered in order to presumably preform blood sacrifices. As the archeologist went through the area, he found several bodies. The narrator implied that this proved that this was a literal gateway to Hell.
No, it doesn’t. For starters, they didn’t do a thorough evaluation of the bodies. For all we know, those were people who died in accidents or of any number of possible causes. And even if they had been murdered and all evidence pointed to sacrifice, what would we know for certain? Well, we would know that the Mayans conducted human sacrifices in the cave. This is conducive to what we know about the dark side of their culture and should come as no surprise, but to say that this means that the cave they are standing in is a literal portal to an Underworld where souls of the wicked are tormented for all eternity is what we call a bit of a stretch.
The entire crockumentary (a term I have just coined to imply a show that is performed in the style of a documentary and is not meant as a mockumentary, but is still a total crock of shit) was laced with this. They had interesting people on discussing the realistic side of these sites and the faithful who interpreted them as hellmouths, but those people were overshadowed by evangelicals with zany eyes saying that Hell is a real place.
They even went so far (though it has nothing to do with a gateway to Hell) as to get a guy on who was a plane crash survivor. He’s heavily scarred from a very harrowing experience, and while being doctored he had a near death experience with a tunnel of light that was lighter and more tunnely than anything on earth, and at the same time he turned his head and saw an evil darkness darker than the darkest darkness that wasn’t this particular darkness but was still plenty dark. The darkness tried to eat him. I know, right?
He attests that his experience was totally real and absolute proof that there is a Hell that is hungry for your soul and all the usual crap, and it didn’t even dispute this fact.
History Channel, you suck. You continuously take what could be interesting fodder for discussion and turn it into sound bytes that you think will sell. If your target audience is birthers, truthers, and other spoon-fed intellectuals, then you’re on the right path. But either way, please just stop.
Jim
“Crocumentary” – I like it. The History Channel (or the pseudohistory channel, or else the “Hitler and UFO Channel” – all of these work) has become inundated with this kind of crap. What used to be a good channel for actual history gets tossed into the dungheap when they discuss religion or things like UFOs. Just looking at what is on later today: “The Naked Archaeologist” (thankfully he isn’t the first, and he is nowhere close to the second), “Prophecies of Iraq” (I can only guess at this), “The Templar Code” (supposed to be about the history, but the title sure doesn’t sound like it). It seems they want to appeal to the lowest common denominator rather than maintain their integrity.
The Templar Code? Ugh. That has got to be about how OMG THE NITES TEMPLUR WERE REAL DAN BROWN NOEZ!
I don’t understand why well put together historical documentaries wouldn’t be absolutely marketable. I’ve seen shows on History that were incredibly good and didn’t have any pawn references in them, yet they put money into funding these crockumentaries. Sigh.
I think it might be worth looking into who owns or has majority stock in these channels. This smells like something of a stealth Religious Right campaign… particularly the bit with the near-death guy. I’ve seen a lot of crockumentaries from the Fundie Brigade with the same scene… near-death guy sees Hell and therefore we have proof it exists.Anyway, something to look into.
History is, at least according to a quick search, part of a large joint venture between NBC/Universal, ABC/Disney, and The Hearst Corporation.
Pingback: On Watching Nova’s Ape Genius | Meddling Kids